The Highlander is a beloved model in the Toyota range, particularly for its rugged reliability and dependability after many miles and years on the road. Though it can be hard to know what to look for when shopping for this venerable SUV, in today’s used SUV buying guide, we’ll be exploring everything you need to know about the Highlander’s anticipated reliability.
Key Takeaways:
- The Highlander combines strong reliability with comfortable three-row family practicality.
- Hybrid models provide improved efficiency but should receive battery health evaluations.
- Maintenance history and interior condition significantly affect long-term ownership value.
What is the best year of the Highlander to buy used?
The best used Toyota Highlander years depend on your priorities, but the 2016 and 2019 models are widely considered the strongest choices. The 2016 Highlander is often praised for its exceptional reliability thanks to its proven 3.5-liter V6 and dependable 6-speed automatic transmission, making it an ideal option for buyers focused on long-term ownership. Meanwhile, the 2019 Highlander delivers a great balance of reliability and modern features, adding Apple CarPlay, Toyota Safety Sense, and an updated 8-speed automatic transmission.
Budget-conscious shoppers can also find excellent value in the 2011–2013 Highlanders, which remain durable and affordable family SUVs.
While the Highlander has an outstanding reputation overall, a few years are better avoided. The 2003–2005 models experienced transmission concerns and potential oil sludge issues, while some 2008–2010 V6 models were known for excessive oil consumption. Early third-generation models from 2014–2015 also received complaints about transmission hesitation and sluggish shifting. For most buyers in today's market, a well-maintained 2016 or 2019 Highlander offers the best combination of reliability, features, and long-term value.
Which Toyota Highlander has the fewest problems?
The Toyota Highlander has built a reputation for long-term reliability, but some model years stand out more than others. Among the best used Toyota Highlanders are the 2007 model, which marked the end of the first generation and offered proven durability, the 2012 model for its balance of value and updated safety features, and the 2016 model, which is widely considered one of the strongest years thanks to its dependable V6 engine, refined interior, and improved technology.
Buyers seeking a more modern SUV may also appreciate the 2021 Highlander, which introduced a redesigned cabin, advanced driver-assistance features, and an available fuel-efficient hybrid powertrain.
Regardless of trim level, the Highlander has consistently delivered strong resale value and low ownership costs. Models such as the 2016 Highlander XLE and Limited offer premium amenities without sacrificing reliability, while newer fourth-generation models provide additional technology and comfort. For most shoppers, choosing a well-maintained Highlander from one of these standout years provides an excellent combination of practicality, durability, and family-friendly versatility.
Used Toyota Highlander Buying Guide: Reliability, Comfort, and Family SUV Value
| Feature | Toyota Highlander |
| Reputation | One of the most reliable and family-friendly midsize SUVs on the market |
| Best Model Years | 2016 and 2019 are widely considered the strongest overall choices |
| Years to Inspect Carefully | 2003-2005 for transmission concerns, 2008-2010 for oil consumption, 2014-2015 for transmission hesitation |
| Common Problems | Oil consumption, transmission hesitation, and age-related wear on older models |
| Available Powertrains | Proven V6 engines and fuel-efficient hybrid variants |
| Hybrid Considerations | Battery health and service history should be evaluated on higher-mileage examples |
Where Can I Buy a Used Toyota Highlander?
Here at St Pete Jarrett Mitsubishi, our used selection includes the Highlander, with the ultra reliable Family SUV being a staple of our used cars, so if you’re looking to get your foot in the door on a well-maintained and serviced Highlander, be sure to shop St. Pete Jarrett Mitsubishi!